The onset of the Q3 earnings reporting season brings the performance of the banking sector into focus. Analysts are closely monitoring these results to gauge whether the sector is on the path to recovery. Currently, bank stocks find themselves trading near their lowest levels of the year, largely due to the collapse of First Republic Bank in May. The KBW Bank Index ($BKX) has endured a -24% decline this year, significantly underperforming the broader S&P 500 Stock Index ($SPX) (SPY), which has seen a +14% gain over the same period.
Bank stocks are facing several headwinds that have contributed to this underperformance. These challenges include the impact of rising interest rates, increased regulatory burdens, and proposed regulatory changes that could impose higher capital requirements on banks. Additionally, unrealized losses in their securities portfolios and a rise in bad loan write-offs have been eroding profitability for many banks. These factors collectively create uncertainty for investors in the banking sector, prompting a cautious approach.
A growing concern for banks is the unrealized losses in their loan portfolios, partly driven by the recent surge in the 10-year Treasury note yield to a 16-year high. This has led to worries that as the Federal Reserve continues to keep interest rates elevated for an extended period, it may result in increased charge-offs for banks due to borrower distress. For example, First Horizon Corp recently anticipated approximately $100 million in aggregate charge-offs for Q3.
Some analysts remain wary about the near-term outlook for bank stocks, noting that the environment remains unsettled. They suggest that Q3 results are likely to confirm a progression of loan losses, albeit from unusually favorable levels. Given the high level of uncertainty, time may be required before a more constructive outlook can be established for bank stocks, as the market grapples with the depth of credit weakness.
Despite these concerns, the results of banks’ Q3 net interest income are drawing attention, particularly due to higher deposit costs as financial institutions vie for business, a situation precipitated by the challenges faced by regional banks such as Silicon Valley Bank in March. However, not all analysts are pessimistic about bank stocks. Citigroup sees bank stocks as undervalued and believes they have the potential for a rebound. UBS, too, suggests that large-cap banks are oversold, attributing the current sentiment to unwarranted concerns rather than fundamental issues.
In conclusion, the investment landscape for bank stocks remains uncertain, marked by challenges such as regulatory changes, rising interest rates, and credit concerns. The near-term outlook is mixed, with some analysts seeing undervalued opportunities while others remain cautious until the path to recovery becomes clearer. Investors should carefully assess the sector and individual bank performances before making investment decisions.
Featured Image: Freepik @ rawpixel.com
Author Faith Yakubu